Care for the skin you have now

A clear comparison

Bag Balm vs Aquaphor for cracked hands, heels and lips after menopause

At a glance

Bag Balm and Aquaphor Healing Ointment are both petrolatum ointments that contain lanolin. Choose Aquaphor if you want glycerin and panthenol added. Choose Bag Balm if you want a shorter ingredient list in a tin for heels, knuckles and cuticles. If you are allergic to lanolin, skip both.

Hands, heels and lips often crack more easily after menopause, and either can help.

Bag Balm Original, 8 oz tin; Aquaphor Healing Ointment, 14 oz jar

Shop the products discussed

On this page

Bag Balm vs Aquaphor at a glance

Bag Balm Original Aquaphor Healing Ointment
Petrolatum content Percentage not stated 41% of the ointment
Ingredients listed Petrolatum, lanolin, paraffin, water, oxyquinoline sulfate Petrolatum, mineral oil, ceresin, lanolin alcohol, panthenol, glycerin, bisabolol
Form of lanolin Lanolin Lanolin alcohol
Added moisturizers Not listed Glycerin, panthenol
Fragrance No added fragrance, per Bag Balm Fragrance-free, per Aquaphor
Pack Tin Jar or tube

The fields come from Bag Balm’s product page, the US drug label for Aquaphor Healing Ointment, checked November 13, 2026.

Which is better for cracked hands and heels?

Both seal water into the skin, which is what cracked skin needs. The American Academy of Dermatology names petrolatum and lanolin among the ingredients to look for in its dry skin advice.

  • Aquaphor adds glycerin and panthenol, which draw in and hold water under the seal.
  • Bag Balm has five ingredients and comes in a tin that suits a bedside table or a bag.

Apply either to damp skin, then cover with cotton gloves or socks at night.

Lips and face

Bag Balm lists chapped lips among its uses, and Aquaphor’s label includes chapped lips. Lanolin causes lip reactions in some people, so stop if your lips sting or swell. For the face, both are heavy; keep them to small dry patches.

Who should skip both?

Anyone with a lanolin or wool alcohol allergy. Plain petroleum jelly or a lanolin-free ointment is the alternative: see Aquaphor vs Vaseline and Aquaphor vs CeraVe Healing Ointment.

Questions

Is Bag Balm safe for people?

Bag Balm’s page says it is safe to use on people and animals and lists dry and chafed skin, cracked hands, split heels and chapped lips.

Does Bag Balm have a fragrance?

Bag Balm says it has no added fragrance.

Which is better for crepey hands?

Neither thickens skin. Used every night, either makes the backs of the hands look smoother by holding in water. Sunscreen on the hands does more over time.

The researched verdict

These are close relatives. Aquaphor adds moisturizers; Bag Balm is simpler. Choose by the list and the pack you prefer, and choose neither with a lanolin allergy.

Sources checked November 13, 2026.

Related comparisons:

Compare before you buy

Shop the products discussed

Choose a product for the job it fills. Check the selected size, current package ingredients and seller before ordering.

Shopping outside the US? The store may take you to a local site in supported countries. Our product research covers the US formulas. Products, sizes, ingredients and availability can differ by country. Check the local listing before buying.

Product buttons and linked photos are affiliate links. Stock, sellers and packaging can change. Each card names the linked size.